Tuesday, October 6, 2009

Homeschoolers vs. Aliens

I have been thinking a lot lately about writing this post. There are so many questions I have about the subject. Sometimes I think that I won't be satisfied unless I make some sort of documentary on the subject. It could be really cool. However, at present I can't do that so I will have to satiate the need by posting some questions for discussion.

I have often sat perplexed at the library after checking out 50 plus books to a homeschooling family, why do these women do it? Is it the need to protect their children from "bad influences" in public school. Do some of them feel that their children really are "gifted" and because of that they can provide their little Einstein with a superior education to help them become a professional genius? Maybe they just really like being around their kids? Do these mothers feel frustrated at the amount of time that is wasted in doing idiotic and unhelpful things at school?

I feel frustrated sometimes with my homeschooling friends. I find it a little harder to connect with them now that Lmx and Lulu are both in public school. It frustrates me that talking to them about education is so difficult. Every problem I have with Lmx and his education becomes a "typical public school" issue for them. I feel like they believe if I was a homeschooler those learning barriers would magically disappear and my life would be come blessed, covered in wool felt and gluten free cookies.

I see the benefits of homeschooling. Rolling out of bed without any pressure to make the bus and go to work would be awesome. Keeping Lmx from children who want to trade Bakugan balls and talk Clone Wars would be kind of nice too. I would like for Lulu to not learn snotty behavior from her best friend Sydney, a girl she met at public school. Does isolating our children from less desirable children help push them in the direction we want them to go in? Is that really helpful in their character development? Maybe it is. I certainly would love my children to only be around children who didn't whine, tease, or talk about pop culture. It would save me many headaches if my kids weren't exposed to that. However, it has already happened. I have already lost that battle. Is it too late to turn back?

I used to love the idea of homeschooling. I still do sometimes. It seems so romantic to me, no schedule to stick to, reading the classics, running around the hills collecting bugs and looking for owl pellets, learning how to sew and cook together. I envison the peace in the house when I get rid of all of our cartoon dvd's and ban Saturday morning cartoons.

Maybe sometime. If I ever do decide to do it, it will be because I am so friggen tired of doing homework at 7 o'clock at night with my kids.

18 comments:

andalucy said...

I was doing homework at 9 pm last night with B. :-(

Anyway, sounds like you answered your own questions to some extent. People homeschool because for them, for whatever reason, the benefits outweight negatives.

athena said...

elementary school seemed like a waste of time. and middle school is a pain in the rear end.

Becky said...

Lucy bottomed lined it.

I would add a couple answers to your questions from my point of view.

I do like hanging out with my kids, always have. I like the time we've had together in hsing. Do I realize they will leave someday? Yep. Not a problem. My job as a mom is basically to put myself out of a job.

Chatting about education with hsing friends probably does have barriers. Most hsers believe they solved a majority of ps problems by hsing. Does that mean there aren't any problems hsing, no. But there also may be some solutions in hsing methods that you could help Lmx do, even though you don't hs.

You do have some stereotypes as to what hsing looks like. Rolling out of bed with no schedule to keep with and a classic in each fist doesn't happen in most hsing homes I know. The idea of isolated children is also tiresome. Yes, a small number of hsers perpetuate this, but the majority of hs families are alive and well within their communities with Scouts, church, volunteering, jobs,.. plain old life. Most hsers don't live in a vaccum.

Your romantic ideas of hsing don't need to happen only by choosing to hs. If you want to learn to sew and cook together, do it. If you want naure walks, take 'em. If you don't want cartoons, pitch 'em or turn 'em off.

Your last sentence was one of the turning points for me when I brought my kids home. I spent 2 hours every day getting everyone ready for school, then the school had them for 6 hours, and then I spent the next 4 hours doing school junk at home. Well, what in the world did the school use "their" 6 hours for?! And when was I ever going to get "MY" time with my children? Yes, I was frustrated with the idiotic and unhelpful things of school.

Becky said...

and I forgot to say...wool felt will be a part of my life much longer than hsing. ;)

Ave said...

Meg, I use stereotypes often in my writing. I love stereotyping, I think it makes reading more fun. It is part of my personal un political correctness.
Many homeschoolers in this area use the "unschooling" approach and do whatever the heck they feel like doing every day. In fact, one of my co workers was an unschooling mother and those were her words that I quoted from about rolling out of bed. She loved homeschooling and is quite inspirational.
Living in a rural area I think I probably see more of that type of thing. I do have friends who actually have a curriculum that they create or purchase. I would say this area has about half and half. Lots of hippies in these parts.
Also, I do see a lot of social lepers among the homeschool crowd. They bring their gang into the library and it is chaos, they wreak serious havoc on my pretty shelves, as well as having an irritating feeling of entitlment. I think this is mostly because their parents are socially awkward and irresponsible but it does give the homeschoolers a bad name.

Like anything that goes against the norm there is bound to be a lot of criticism. Thanks for your thoughts.

Anonymous said...

Stereotypes are often based on some kind of reality especially when talking about your own experience. It only becomes 'wrong' (if that’s the word I'm looking for) when stereotyping abstract ideas or certain social groups especially if you have never had any contact with a particular social group. Still, it is something to be weary of.

I don't think homeschooling is good for everyone and not all homeschool moms are good at it. It would have been better for Paris if he was homeschooled in high school. As a dyslexic the school did nothing but put him in a lower group where he was bored. I had to give him homework myself. Unfortunately the laws here do not allow homeschooling. Meg, on the other hand, is much better off at school so its really individual.

As for those hs moms being snotty, they are just insecure themselves about their decision. If they weren't they would respect others for whatever decision they make. So there!If you want I can get Uncle Shawn down there to beat them up.

Anonymous said...

Truths: Lucy is right, and Aunty. It really is an individual issue. Ask Mum! She homeschooled Lex and me until I begged to go back to public school. Levi chose not to go back so he went 5th grade through high school graduation homeschooled. Sam never set foot in a class room until he was a junior or senior in high school. Jacob started in 4th grade, then went back to homeschool when we moved to Saipan, then we back to public school. The youngest three started out in public school, then Mum put them in a private school on Saipan.

I love the idea of homeschooling, especially now that I'm actually studying education. I feel that there is a lot of wasted time in the public schools. But I also remember LOVING public school. I think the important thing to remember is to try and provide your children with what each of them need. I know some parents who do a mixture of public and homeschooling. On Saipan, Mum did a lot of group homeschooling with other families. In Maine, even when we were homeschooled, we were entitled to participate in public school plays and athletics. Hey, we're tax payers too!

Or you can just wait until I set up my dream private school with Alexa and we can provide incredible private schooling at no cost.

jori-o said...

I have considered hs--but M and I would clash big time---just helping him with homework is a big production. K would do alot better and we seriously considered it this year because of some issues at her school, but she begged to go to school, so we're trying things with a new teacher, a fresh schoolyear. Things are better. As a parent, you have to be pretty involved in pub. school anyway for your kid to really benefit.

Mama Ava said...

If anyone had EVER told me I'd homeschool, I would never have believed it. It was the best choice for our son and we are still reaping the benefits. If anyone suggests I homeschool son #2 I may run screaming out the door. It would not be a good mix.

You don't know what you're capable of doing until you need to do what's best for your child or your family. I agree that it's not supposed to come naturally. I'm a teacher and teaching your own child is not the same.

People hs for all sorts of different reasons, some of which I don't agree with. But I am so glad we had the option and the freedom to do it. I'm appalled at some of the attitudes I've heard towards hs'ers. I think when it's done to avoid something, it tends to not be very good. When it's done as a part of a family decision and values, then it's much better. I have not always liked some of the things my kids have come home with--but I have felt confident in our ability to parent our values and expectations. Things we believe make us swim against the popular culture tide and it's something that our kids will have to manage in their lives.

I also hate homework. From 6-9 every night I fervently wish I didn't have to teach all day so that I could have the energy to do homework at night. Isn't it funny that I don't wish they had less or no homework?

andalucy said...

I meant to say "outweigh" not "outweight." :-) Although "outweight" is quite a funny word and could have its own uses.

I was thinking more about this today. When I started homeschooling it was because G was bored stiff in school. Yes, I did feel that I could provide my "Little Einstein" a superior education and I did. She made rapid progress. We enjoyed our time together and we got along much better than we had before we started homeschooling. G went back to public school only because she had the opportunity to go to the Spanish immersion school. Xinnia really enjoyed homeschooling too. I haven't let Mateo and Stella homeschool yet for various reasons, but I hope they can some day. Since they are only at school for five hours here in Spain, we have plenty of time together.

I wouldn't trade my time homeschooling for anything. That experience enriched the culture of our home. It made me feel empowered. I now feel greater competence in guiding my children's education after all the research I've done on education and homeschooling. I met wonderful people like Meg, Cocoa, Athena, Mama Ava, and Karen that I intend to be my lifelong friends. (So you'd better not try squirm out of my life, ya'll!)

Someone who is socially awkward is not going to learn social grace at public (or private) school. He or she will only be made to feel more keenly their lack in that area when forced into an arena where that's all that matters.

MJ said...

I wrestle back and forth about whether or not I want to homeschool my kids. I guess it will depend on the condition of the school system we're living in when my kid starts school.

I personally hated school. Public school sucked for me. I was one of those people who graduated from high school and NEVER looked back. My friends from that era who I'm still close to today are my church friends.

However, I have seen the cons of strictly homeschooling some kids. They don't aquire any "street smarts", in a sense. One friend's younger brother got himself into a WORLD of trouble--we're talking jail time, and a criminal record--all because he wanted to fit in with a group of boys who weren't that great of friends.

Would he have done what he did had he NOT been homeschooled? I can't really say either way. Maybe if he'd been exposed to public schools and the undesirable things that happen (bullying, bratty best friends, etc) within reason, he might have had the gumption to tell these particular friends to kiss off. Or maybe not. Maybe he's just the type of person who wants so badly to be accepted that he ignores the consequences of his actions.

It's a hard thing, being a parent, and finding the fine line between helping your kids grow and become awesome adults and protecting them from the bad out in the world.

Anonymous said...

Wow, people really have strong feelings about this. I guess it just goes to show you those hsers that try to make you feel bad are also questioning themselves. They probably go to the library to have a sort of hs support group and when they come across someone who doesn't do it they don't know what to say. It's just one of those things. Don't sweat it.

Ave said...

Thank you for all of the comments. They have been entertaining and insightful.
Lucy, I disagree to some extent on the whole social awkward thing. I suffer from some sort of disorder which makes me blurt out asinine things from time to time in public places or with a group of friends.
I will go home and think crap, that was so embarrassing that I did that...
School helped me learn the hard way not to be so crazy, and you know, I think it did help me significantly about compassion and bullying. Sure, I still say dumb things, I did so last night at a town meeting. Oh well.
How do kids learn to cope with their weirdo behavior if they aren't exposed to some sort of ridicule at a young age?
Before anyone freaks out about bullying, I don't mean bullying. I think that is a cruel thing and something that I never participated in and loathed. However, can't we be bullied as adults too? Wouldn't experiencing that as a child help us learn to deal and prevent? I digress, I really am more specifically talking about odd behavior, like mine.;)

Anonymous said...

Hahaha! Ave, that's not a disorder, that's just genes!

I agree with Ave that public school does help with some social awkwardness. It's not a matter of being able to deal with mean people, bad things, etc., necessarily. It has a lot more to do with the fact that if you don't practice being around people it's more difficult to know how to act around them. It happens with adults to.

But like I said, it really depends on the kids, and on the school district and on if you want to or not and if you feel you can or not. Just believe me when I say, you can accomplish a lot more than you probably think.

Emily said...

You are a good mom to be concerned about the topic at all.

I am glad that there are people, like you, who ask the hard questions and try to find out the best solutions for themselves and their families.

It definitely has to be a personal decision...no one can make the choice for you. Sometimes that is really hard...especially with so many different voices yelling so many different things.

Obviously, do what YOU feel is best for YOUR family.

Best of luck in whatever you decide.

Have a great weekend!

Gabriela said...

Hi Ave. Looks like you've found a hot topic here.

I'm sure I could do it if I had to-like if I felt my kids were unsafe-but other than that, hs is not for me.

Of course I have the normal issues with "regular" school (busy work, curriculum, class size). Sometimes I feel like I need to supplement what they're learning a bit. But, I think learning to be with and work with people that are different from you (both teachers and students) and developing and practicing social skills provide lifelong benefits.

Living how we live, I haven't come in conact with many families that do, so it will be interesting to go back to the States and see how my feelings about it change.

(I love reading your sterotypes, I feel like I'm having a lively conversation with you)

Emily said...

I had to comment again....but completely off the topic.

I LOVE baby names. I think about them ALL the time and I love that you added some in your comment. Oliver IS super cute...since my maiden name is Olive, that would be fun. But I think we are going to stick with the first initial 'M'....just because we can. Any suggestions? :)

You are adorable, by the way.

andalucy said...

If it is important to a family that their children learn social graces, they will learn them whether they are schooled at home or in a building somewhere. Going to school could help children learn valuable social skills, yes. They could also pick up some anti-social behavior/attitudes there. My point was only that I don't see 'socialization' (can't stand that word) as being a reason to choose one or the other.