Just so you know, I am high on bathroom cleaning products right now. I was furiously scrubbing the tub when I started thinking about my sister's blog on teens, when this topic came to me and I just had to stop and write about it for a while.
About two years ago I was checking out an Ian McEwan book to a library patron. My co worker said "oh that is a really good book." When the patron brought it back I picked it up and read it. The book was about two young people who get married in the 1960's and can't figure out how to consummate their marriage. It is fairly typical of the subject where the girl is scared and the bumbling boy can't figure out how to communicate honestly and effectively, the story just gets worse from there. I will have to say it is really well written, like all of McEwans books, but very very depressing.
After I read it I was talking to my co workers about it, I said "there is no way that they couldn't have figured it out. I mean, we are all animals aren't we? Animals do it. We see it all the time. There isn't any way she couldn't have known." My co worker responded "you didn't grow up at that time, you don't know. It was the 60's, people didn't talk about sex." I laughed at this and still stated that the book was unbelievable.
Now though, I am starting to wonder. The book was essentially about communication and culture. Lucy's recent post about teens reminded me that Christians are way behind in the sex and communication department. Pop culture is inundated with sexual imagery. The programs that kids watch on network tv in the evenings glorify casual sex. It is expected. The media teaches our children that sex is like a buffet table. You just keep sampling until you get the right thing, and after that, it is ok if you want to give up ranch dressing and go back to balsamic vinaigrette. After all, life is too short...
My issue is how are the Christian churches that value chastity and fidelity fighting the problem of cultural influence? I know that when I was a kid we had "Standards Night." I dreaded this. We were herded into a stuffy church room with our church leaders and told to be "chaste." We didn't have any other information. Some Christian kids thought that kissing was a no- no before marriage. Some thought that anything goes as long as you don't actually do the deed. A lot of us just stuck to the old standard, "don't let anyone touch your private parts." We were kind of on our own, trying to figure out and deal with it all. The leaders of Standards Night had a catchy phrase for the time "sex is not secret, it is sacred." Please. Is that what we are going to arm our kids with, lame phrases like that? A phrase that might as well be, "oh, you'll figure it out, and it's wonderful!" Barf. Then we were dismissed for refreshments.
Times have changed. A religion that doesn't talk about things is a dying one. We need to step it up a bit. We need to get these kids out of a church building when trying to talk about serious subjects and into a place where they feel comfortable and safe, and separated by gender. How the crap does one get honest feedback from a group of mixed company at that age?
There are LDS writers who have tried to tackle the subject for young married couples. I have seen books with really cheesy covers about physical intimacy available in Deseret book. I appreciate their attempts and I am sure they help some people, but the talking has to start BEFORE marriage. Christians need to feel less scared, and more honest about talking to teens about sex.
Teens need to know exactly why it can be a blessing to have only one sex partner, and after you are married. They need to know the logic, not just the commandment. Any thoughts?
*I really am trying to be serious here. Hopefully I won't have to turn on comment moderation.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
11 comments:
1- I asked Molly, "How was your meeting?" as she came in the door from last year's "Standard Night" chat and her response - as she skipped up the stairs to change..."We're still supposed to stay away from evil..."
Yep, that about wraps it up.
2-I think it's don't think it's up to churches, schools, books etc...to teach kids the counter to every cultural influence. *Ideally* it's up to the parents. Home should be the ultimate counterculture for what you would like your children to avoid.
That scripture about he who must be commanded in all things is a slothful servant...don't quote me directly...comes to mind. Churches teach "The Law" - what ever it is - and homes are responsible to teach obedience in all it's forms.
I agree Meg, it is ultimately up to parents, but so many people just don't feel comfortable talking directly to their children about sex. They can't even bring themselves to say the word in a way that isn't weird and uncomfortable for the children. I think it definitely needs to start when kids are young and first beginning to notice modesty. For example, when we go into a toy store and Lulu sees those bratts dolls and asks if she can have one I say "No, those girls are wearing gross clothes. Look, you can see that her breasts are falling out and if she bent over in that skirt you could see her underwear. ick. Let's find a doll that has nice clothes."
Parents need to be more matter of fact about things, I think that is one way to make kids feel comfortable.
Maybe we should do away with Standards Night all together. It seems so ineffective to me.
My mom gave us the 'basics talk' when we were 8 years old. Then she was incredibly open about the subject whenever we had questions. She didn't try to skirt around the issue or sugar coat it. She gave us facts and we were satisfied. I am sure it wasn't the most comfortable thing for her to talk to her growing children about sex...but she felt it was part of her job as our mom. How grateful I am for that.
That's how I want my kids to learn. Definitely not from the 'world' or even the church.
I love that you teach your kids about modesty so frankly. I am passionate about the subject and it might have been on my kids' first-5-words-they-ever-spoke list.
Your kids are certainly lucky to have you.
While going through a difficult family time, I received some of the best advise of my parenting life -- Tell them the truth, then let their questions be the guide of how much they currently want to know.
Oh and then you have to answer any and all of their questions factually and honestly. Yes, it is a bit uncomfortable, but (I hope that) time bears a positive witness that this path works well for our family.
What's all this about feeling comfortable? Not everything in life is comfortable but it needs to be done. I talked to my kids about it when I felt they needed to hear it and I did not embellish. Just get on with it. I didn't really feel 'comfortable' about changing diapers *gross* but it needed to be done. People can be such freaks.
Paris is kind of feeling weird about how the church deals with sex because when he was a teen it was 'stay away from evil' and 'chastity' then he turned 18 and all the activities for over 18s is how to get them paired up and married. Its a bit twisted that way and a number of kids just don't go to the activities anymore but instead they get together and have their own sort of un-official church activity.
Yeah, I know what you mean Lee. Being LDS and 18 is hard, you aren't interested in getting married at that age, thank goodness, and that seems to be all that the formal activities are focused on. I'm glad that the kids do there own thing and still get together. Friendship is the most important factor at that age. Good for you for being ok with being uncomfortable. You are absolutely right. Diapers are nasty, and we are supposed to do things that stretch our personal boundries.
great point Dave, and I saw on your Max blog that things are looking so much brighter! I am so happy for you and your family. I will keep you guys in my prayers.
Hey Ave, thanks for the positive thoughts for Max - he was in my son's 1st Grade Class and has been out of school for about eight months now - but it appears that things are moving in a good direction now. I'll pass along your well wishes.
It sounds like Dave's approach to teaching his kids is the same as my mum's.
I don't think we can compare changing diapers with talking about sex. I have no emotional, psychological, or physical reaction when I change diapers. (I do have a verbal one though: Ugh! Wow! You are amazing, kid!) Sex though, yeah, I have a lot of reactions and attachments to it. I think that's at least one reason why it's so difficult for parents to address it.
I completely agree though that it needs to be addressed by the parents. The best standards night I ever went to was when I was, oh, about 15 or 16 and we had a panel and anonymous questions (written on note cards and sent up with leaders bunches at a time). It was definitely the most non-invasive one.
It is amazing I wasn't scared out of my wits when it came time. I had a young women's president who taught my laurels class one time and said things like, "It's different for women then for men. It's important to know that you aren't doing anything wrong, even though the first time, or maybe even the first five or six times, it feels like you've been violated." Wow. I'm surprised I'm not celibate. After a couple of instances like that you'd think I would be.
There is a quote by Elder ... Nelson? about sex in marriage. It's great! I'll try to find it.
My mom was an RN whilst I was growing up, so sex was a matter-of-fact conversation, and because she was so open to answering any questions my friends and I might have, it didn't ever become taboo.
I'm not an RN. And I AM a little nervous about talking to my kids about sex, what is and is not appropriate from our religious perspective, but it still needs to be done. I'm all for drawing a SPECIFIC line for my kids, so they know what is appropriate for what age. (Group dates at 16, pairing off at 30, lol)
I didn't grow up thinking sex was BAD, like so many of my more sheltered friends, so the transition from single to married wasn't as difficult (there were still some times that I struggled, but I wasn't frigid by any means, lol). But I spent too much time worrying about what I was doing WRONG, rather than what I was doing RIGHT.
But I agree with Dave's idea of giving them the facts and letting them ask the questions.
I think the real key is the willingness to talk, listen, and not judge. The thing that made such a difference in my relationship with my parents is that they always had my back when it counted, even if they didn't agree with my decisions.
Post a Comment