I have decided that I don't really believe that there is such thing as agnostic. I think that agnostic simply defines a state of denial, hurt, vulnerability, and pride, suppressing the spirit.
I believe that an agnostic person wants to believe in God deep down in his or her soul, but circumstance prevents this from occurring.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
10 comments:
I find it strange that lots of people believe in some kind of 'greater being' or an 'entity of greater good' but the same people do not believe in an 'entity of bad' or greater evil. How can you have one without the other? duh!
I feel sad sometimes for people who don't believe. I get such great comfort, strength, direction and hope from my faith I just want others to feel it to.
That said, I've also had times when I question but the positive benefits overwhelm the alternative.
so you do believe in agnosticism, or rather that one can be agnostic, you just believe in a different definition. i think that to a certain extent agnosticism has some claim, maybe one can never know the logical value of GOD, i mean isn't that the whole point of faith?
Yes, Bob I have many friends who claim they are "agnostic." However, knowing these individuals I came up with my own definition based on my experience of them.
I think for a lot of people it isn't cool to believe in a higher power, so they don't. I have friends who are not Christian, but who are "spiritual" people and I do not consider them agnostic, just those who deny that there is a God or a spiritual element to human nature.
The term "agnostic" is applied specifically to those who don't know for certain whether or not God exists. An agnostic is one who believes that the existence of God is unknown and most likely beyond human ability to discover.
By definition, an agnostic is not committed to believing in or disbelieving in the existence of God. Nevertheless, while agnosticism claims to "sit on the fence," many agnostics are "practical atheists," in that they actively pursue the atheistic lifestyle; that is, they tend to subscribe to moral relativism and live out their lives without any concern for ultimate accountability.
I have always viewed agnostics as "weak" and I suppose your comments will be filled with people blasting that choice of words. I agree that my faith has provided me with such strength and comfort and direction--it is impossible for me to not believe. At the same time, I can accept someone who is so rational that the idea of God simply is not possible, just as I can accept peope of different faiths without accepting their beliefs.
When I have doubts, it is never about the existence of God. It usually boils down to my difficulty in understanding or accepting or in resisting the desire to control things.
Agnostics...I don't get. Either there is Someone who is in charge and guiding/directing with a purpose, or there is not and things are rational and explainable and scientifically possible and proveable. To say, "maybe, maybe not, who can tell" seems like hedging your bets. Or are agnostics willing to say the believe that God exists but are not willing to follow a faith that dictates certain principles of behavior?
And the word "spiritual" is so wishy-washy that I don't know what it means anymore. That you hang crystals and celebrate the solstice? That you celebrate Christmas but don't go to church? That you go to church, but you're all "religious or anything"? That you meditate? I really don't get that. Often when people try to explain, they seem to be saying they are moral or ethical people, which is not the same as spiritual, and obviously possible for people to be who are agnostic or athiest.
Sorry if I opened a can of worms on your blog, Ave.
Mama Ava, I get what you're saying about agnostics being wishy-washy. Atheism requires a lot of faith. Atheists have their dogma and everything. Agnostic is like, Whatever. To me it seems that Agnosticism is more about not caring one way or another. I wonder if perhaps many agnostics, if given irrefutable evidence that God existed, would even care. Have you read 'A Severe Mercy?' It's about (among other things) an agnostic couple who converts to Christianity.
i couldn't disagree more with the whole "weak" and "wishy-washy" definition, but then again i guess to me agnosticism is very philisophical in the approach that nothing can be known with any certainty, that all things (and most cerntainly theologically speaking) can be disproven. i don't know but it sounds like maybe the people you've mentioned who define themselves as agnostic are actually just calling themselves that because they really don't care one way or the other. however, for few people i have met that define themselves as such it is not that they are "wishy-washy" it's that they actually believe that the existance of GOD can't be proven either way. and if you think about it, if the existance of GOD was provable (and i mean in the agnostic sense) then faith would be pointless.
I am aware of the actual definition of agnostic, however, what I am finding is that many people are refering to themselves these days as "agnostic" because they choose not to want to believe in anything at all. A lot of these people shun Christianity and most types of religion including ones that are more spiritual and less organized. Websters doesn't seem to have a word for these folks so I just call them what they call themselves.
Mama Ava, I agree with many of your points. As someone who has struggled with faith my whole life I can see the allure of "spiritualism" and by that I mean crystals and solstice, as apposed to Christianity. No callings, no one bugging you to do churchy stuff all the time, no accountability. After all, who likes to be accountable?
My mother always told me that people who are members of religions that celebrate spirit but not necessary God and Jesus, were like stepping stones on the path to truth.
I definitely have felt that agnostics are weak. As far as wishy washy, I go back and forth on that one all the time. ;)
Mama Ava, I like what you say about your doubts not being about God, but about your own understanding. That's exactly how I feel. I often challenge things I hear in my own faith, but after looking into it or even just thinking about it a little deeper and finding some legitimacy, I decide it's largely my own lack of understanding or faith that causes me to be confused or (sometimes) upset about something.
Bob, I entirely disagree that theology can be disproved any easier than philosophy. I think there is too much that points to the existence of some kind of supernal being that many aspects of most spheres of theology are all too provable. I think it comes down to people's limited abilities to understand the eternal laws of science.
i didn't say that theology was easier to disprove then philosophy, i said that philosophically speaking all things, including theology, are to some extent disprovable. also, what is provable to one may not be to another, therefore proof in itself is easily deniable and hard to define.
ave, you should do more of these types of topics i always love the discussions they provoke!
Post a Comment