Before I mentioned that I have some particular issues with Classical education. From what I have read online, a Classical education is heavy on literature, classic literature, renaissance artists, mathematics, and science (except for dawinism). The idea seems to be that these focuses are superior and of the highest importance for creating a well rounded intellectual child.
The idea I applaud. However, many of the people that I read about who are attempting to implement this type of home school study, or those who I know that have a Classical focus for their program I find deficient in the "normal" category. These are the people who snub books like Magic Treehouse because they are contemporary and a little silly. Some of these parents seem to have issues with letting their children explore their own interests. This is my main problem with home schooling parents that enforce a Classical education only or bust rule. I think it is suffocating to the mind.
When I was a little girl I enjoyed fairy tales. I loved nursery rhymes, the Greek gods and goddesses fascinated and repulsed me. I loved crafts and would have learned to knit and felt if anyone showed me how (I would have been the ideal Waldorf student). My husband would have been bored to tears. Classical education is not beneficial for all students.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
I gotcha. It's not so much the theory as the enforcement. Which I have no disagreement with.
You are right it would not be for everyone. I am happy to be one that would not want to fit the mold.I guess I would have been a blacksmith or woodworker in the days gone by.
JW
I agree. You can't force kids into learning things they don't want to learn. You can however make them interested - which is what you have to do for the things like (in my case) math.
The world today is so full of information. I think kids get bombarded with a lot more info then I ever did. Its more difficult to choose what they should learn. There is also a difference between alfa's, beta's and gamma's in what people want to learn. Like you said, what you liked JW would have been bored with. It must be difficult to make a curriculum for 30 kids that are all different.
When my kids were exposed to literature from around the world, I bemoaned the lack of classics. When they got the classics, I bemoaned the overfocus on Western literature.
I guess that's where the word "balance" comes in.
when we homeschooled we used the classical method and i think our children were pretty normal. =) when we sent them to school (specifically here in the US) they were far above their class mates in world history. classical education isn't for everyone but it would sure help to have a bit of it back.
Post a Comment