I was talking to a co worker today for a couple of minutes about religion and hypocrisy. I hear about it from people who do not affiliate themselves with any sort of organized religion a lot. Here are some of my thoughts.
People hate hypocrites. They do. I think it is something that is universally seen as weak and loathsome.
Religious zealots are often seen as hypocrites because of the high standards they set for themselves and for those around them. They preach a gospel that is impossible for anyone to follow completely, therefore are caught in hypocrisy.
People expect a person who is active in any form of church to live the values taught in that faith. When someone steps out of line, it is noted and often held against them.
We are all hypocrites because we are imperfect and human.
I recently read a biography of Martin Luther King jr. At first I was disgusted by his duplicity. I felt let down by his philandering and disregard for women. I thought "What a swine. Why do we celebrate this jerk?" Then reflecting more about it I realized that I was doing exactly what drives me nuts. I wasn't letting him be human. I was holding him to a standard that was not totally applicable to his time and culture. He was acting biblical in some ways, using women to relieve himself and going about his business like so many in the Old Testament did, and so many men have done though out time. It isn't attractive and it isn't right, but that was what he did. He still helped shape a nation, he still inspired. I think he still deserves to have a holiday named and inspired by him.
Is it wrong to teach children that these men were great men, when they are just regular men with great ideas?
Hypocrisy doesn't seem to me a logical reason to hate organized religion. Religion is as imperfect as the people who follow it. That doesn't mean it isn't true, helpful, or pertinent to growing compassion and love. It will always be that way until we all die and find the ultimate truth.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
7 comments:
I think of a hypocrite as someone who hides behind a facade for personal gain. The Savior called the hypocritical Jewish leaders of his day "whited sepulchres" because they gave an outward appearance of righteousness, but were evil within.
I don't think of people who try to be good because they feel it's the right thing to do as hypocrites just because they succumb to human weaknesses and fail to live up to what they truly desire to be.
The way I read it, our heart's desires are extremely important.
The definition of a hypocrite is someone who believes and preaches one thing and does another, so that is really all of us at times. It is to a lesser extent for sure then one who is hypocritical for the sake of say money or power.
If you estrange yourself from religion you can push away the guilt and feel better then all of the "religious hypocrites," sitting in the pews at church when you know they've been sinning up a storm.
I know from friends who have left the LDS faith that "hypocrisy" comes up a lot when they talk about why they left and why they will never come back to organized religion.
It fascinates me.
I think the definition of hypocrisy depends on the accuracy of the dictionary you use. For example, the dictionary definition I just pulled up sited "pretense" as a synonym and defined it as "an attempt to make something that is not the case appear true."
I think it's safe to say that most people would agree that if you strive to live what you preach--despite succumbing to human weakness at times because you are human--you are not a hypocrite. You are simply human.
Regardless, I think people who leave the LDS faith or other religions because of "hypocrisy" may really be seeing hypocrisy in some of the members (unfortunately) but mostly are not understanding that the Church doesn't expect us to be without flaw, but that it does expect us to strive to correct and repent of those flaws.
I realize that meaning is one of several found in most dictionaries, but I'm sure you would agree that it is a simplistic definition at best that does not truly convey the strong and generally understood nuances of meaning associated with the word.
Okay--I'll admit that it's a definition I've used myself in my more cynical days. I'm trying to be "without guile", but for me it's a mountainous struggle!
Continuing a little with the semantics, James's definition of religion is "to visit the fatherless and widows in their affliction, and to keep himself unspotted from the world." Definitely a higher meaning.
Thanks for getting me thinking a little...sometimes it's nice to know I still can. :)
I think MLK was certainly hypocritical as a minister of the gospel, but that this doesn't take away from his greatness in connection to the important work for civil rights. Just in the same way that Einstein's less-than- pleasant personal life doesn't detract from his contributions to physics.
good discussion ladies. you have given me some excellent points to ponder.
Good post! You have such amazing thoughts and words. I think your header quote sums it up best...'stepping forward, then sliding back along with everyone else' so true, so true!
Post a Comment