My auntie Lee is up on current affairs. I enjoy reading her thoughts, especially since she has a more global perspective having been a US citizen living in the Netherlands for the past 20 years.
Today she posted an interesting fact on facebook concerning American penitentiaries. According to her source America has more convicts in prison then the rest of the world. We will not import goods made from slave labor, yet we sell things that our inmates make and do not pay them for their work.
Auntie didn't give her opinion on the matter either way, but it really got me thinking. What is wrong with our judicial system? Why do we arrest so many people? Are our prisons helpful to these criminals?
John and I have long endorsed the idea of bringing back the chain gang. I honestly think that this is a great idea. Here in Maine, prisoners do volunteer pick up of trash along the side of the road. I have seen young buff men picking up trash in their jump suits several times along the road side. They are being pro active. They are doing something. They are improving themselves. Some people go to jail, sit in their cell and watch tv all day. They aren't required to do physical work. They get depressed. They cause riots. What if they were too tired to cause riots because they were working in a field planting crops, so that they could eat delicious healthy vegetables instead of that prison food crap.
How would this change their behavior?
When you do physical labor you have time to think, time to contemplate life in the silence.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
It's important to keep in mind that slave labor is different from the labor of people who have broken the law. They lose the common rights because of what they've done.
I do think something needs to be done about the number of people we have in prison because it's ridiculously expensive to keep them there. I think volunteer work is excellent and we need more of it from people in general, and certainly from these people.
I think inmates who behave well have many more opportunities to work than they used to. Have you heard the This American Life program about the murderers performing Hamlet? Awesome.
http://www.thisamericanlife.org/Radio_Episode.aspx?episode=218
The problem is, why are there so many in jail in the first place. Not, what are they doing when they get there. Personal observation in my family says such things like The Bill of Rights simply does not exist in many States anymore. In Florida you can be in jail for 6 months without being charged. During that time you work hard labour. That is fundamentally wrong! Unfortunately it is not legally wrong. This is the definition of 'slave labour'. That is a fact, what one's opinion is, is another thing.
Chain gangs are usually meant for people who have commited a crime.
I don't know why there is such a high number. I've hear it has to do with the three stikes thing but I have also heard that America is more of a violent country (don't know about that). I'm sure there are a number of reasons but none of them can be good.
Have you researched this or is your information mostly anectodal (which is not to say that it can't be correct)? Have you considered that more people in prison may be a result of stricter laws? My point is what do you know as opposed to what do you believe? Misinformation often causes additional problems in "the system."
Fabulous idea and well said....as usual.
My children ask me the same thing. I say, they have these things now called books and encyclopedias and they also have Google. Look it up. Its most interesting.
Post a Comment