Saturday, July 11, 2009

Glad I Ain't Too Pretty

Like my title? I think it sounds sort of Sedaris-ish.

I was early for work today, had some time to just sit and let my mind spin without interruption. I thought about my mother and the infamous time that she told my brother and I that she was glad that she didn't have children that were "drop dead gorgeous." She then proceeded to tell us about the few drop dead gorgeous children that she knew, and how extreme beauty can actually be a handicap for someone. I remember laughing and rolling my eyes at the thought. It seemed completely absurd to me. I wasn't offended that my mother didn't consider me drop dead gorgeous, I am a realist and know my limitations. We like to tease her about it now, although this I admit is a little cruel.

I overhear many conversations between parents at work. Parents concerned for their children because they are having difficulties at school. This seems to embarrass most parents, like they have socially failed some how. Then their are the parents that make me sigh with a little disgust and irritation because they are telling their friend how the school just really isn't challenging their child, and blah blah blah about their gifted children.

Why does the latter bug me so much? I think it might be because when I was little I was considered both by my teachers. I was telling a friend about this and she laughed out loud, like she didn't believe me, but it is true. I was with the resource teacher in 5th grade for my inability to keep up with the class in math. All through jr. high I had to have tutors and get extra help, yet I was in the advanced English class and the gifted and talented art program. I was one of the best saxophone players and NEVER practiced. Yet I was denied acceptance into the circle of "gifted" kids because I sucked at math.

Now that I am the parent of two very bright children I see the temptation to stereotype a child as gifted. Gifted can rationalize bad behavior from a child acting like a little crap because he doesn't want to listen to directions from a teacher. Gifted can excuse hyperactivity and lack of physical exercise. Gifted can be the reason why little Judy won't play well with other kids and would rather sit and recite math facts and all of the vice presidents of the United States and Prime Ministers of England.

My point of this post is that we are indeed all gifted. God gave each of us talents. I feel that our society is stuck in the mind set that traditional academic achievement equals intelligence and success.

I am glad to be the proud parents of two normal kids. They aren't too pretty, and they aren't too smart. Lmx is clever with numbers and critical thinking. Lulu has all the charm in the world, and can sometimes beat me with puzzles. Mum was right. The middle is just fine.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

I don't know about you not having drop dead gorgeous children... they're pretty wicked cute. And you know, the middle is fine, just like the bottom and the top are fine too. It really comes down to the kid's personality and how the parents raise him/her. The thing I think a lot of parents don't realize is that by the time their adults, their "gifted" children are just about average. Mum and Dad have a good friend from college who I guess was some wiz-kid when he was younger -- and he's still a bright guy, that's for sure -- but he has a fairly average, stable job, makes a good amount of money for his large family, and lives a pretty normal life. He's no Bill Gates heir or anything, ya know?

andalucy said...

It's been interesting through the years to see my kids sometimes classified as gifted by the schools and sometimes not. But this I know: it is hard for children who are in the top 2-3 percentile for IQ to have their needs met in school. It's a legitimate complaint, as annoying as it may be to hear their parents groan about it. So let's drop the 'gifted' label if that bugs you, and just call them 'children of extremely high IQ." CoEHIQ or something. :-) Whatever. Anyway, my experience is that parents who really have kids up in that range don't talk about it much. They often spend a lot of time worrying about how to help their children socially and meet their intellectual needs. Being ultra smart like that sometimes makes it more challenging to excel in school and later life. There is a big difference between very bright children (top 5-10 percent IQ), who usually do very well in school, and the real geniuses who may need a radically different system. We do need to nurture children who have that kind of genius because they could some day make major contributions to society as inventors, researchers, etc.

Just my .02.

andalucy said...

Oh, and sorry to say, but your kids do fall into the extreme cuteness and high hilarity categories. Deal.

Ave said...

Lucy, I think that you are right, there is a huge difference between the real geniuses in a school, let's say 1 per hundered if that, and very bright children. What I find so unfortunate is we see very bright children seperated and celebrated as "gifted", leaving the rest of the student population to be "average." This is where I think the system fails. I understand that very bright children need to be challenged. Great. Challenge away. However, children who have other gifts that are not academic fall through the cracks and are valued less by their peers. I think schools should find a way to celebrate all of the students.
Thankfully the cream does eventually rise to the top. Albert Einstein, Thomas Edison, W.B. Yeats, Norman Rockerfeller, Charles Schwabb, and many more were all told that they were "dumb" by their school peers and teachers, yet they became highly celebrated and successful.
I am grateful to belong to a church that celebrates individual gifts. We have this lesson of talents at church all the time and I am reminded of what can be achieved with a little effort and discipline.

Anonymous said...

This everyone needs a ribbon thing has got to stop. we are setting kids up for failure later in life. if someone is wicked shmart they should get the pat on the head, if someone is not they should not be made to feel less. as i child i would project those less then ribbon worthy feelings upon my self and that is something that i needed get over. some are smart some are commfortable in society, we need to grow and learn academically and emotionally. I think my kids are wicked cunning.
JW