So you know all the blah blah about Judge Sotomayer's comment on being a Latina woman...
"I would hope that a wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would more often then not reach a better conclusion then a white male who hasn't lived that life."
JW was in a snit about it. When I heard Sotomayer's comment I said "big deal, who cares."
JW said something about if a white man said the same thing. blah blah
Then he got to the point that many a talk radio guy has made, and this point did ring true to me. The point being that a Supreme Court Justice or any judge for that matter, isn't being elected to have pathos, she isn't being elected because she has walked with sinners of all walks of life and can use her experiences to help her make good judgements. No, people. A judge doesn't make emotional decisions, she uses the law. The lawyers may plead for mercy, but a judge administers justice. She isn't there to be grandmas ample bosom to cry on. She is there to kick some judicial can.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
In theory judges try to make legal judgments but in practice they use their emotions. You just have to watch judge Judy to see that. It is the inadequacy of being human. Laws are also hypocritical by nature. For every law pointing in one direction their is another one pointing in the other mostly because they are politically based.
I hardly think being Latin would make her any better at her job then any other race. Certainly if she was from a poor background and had to work her way up it would be more refreshing then most of the shirts that are in the judge seats. Maybe that is what she meant, if so, you would think a well educated person could word it better.
Post a Comment