Wednesday, August 6, 2008

The Case Against Alcohol

One of my friends told me a while ago that her father made the following statement (not verbatim but close) "I don't see any reason why we shouldn't make cigarettes and alcohol illegal." This surprised me a little, as this particular fellow is not affiliated with any religion, and enjoys or enjoyed tipping back a Bud or two back in the day. He did however come to the conclusion that he would just as well do without if it would have a positive effect on our society and cut down insurance costs. I guess he forgot about the years of Prohibition.

This friend was perturbed by the statement the old man made and thought it short sighted, because why should she have to give up her right to consume whatever the heck she wants.

I have been contemplating this subject for years. Being an active member of the LDS church I obviously really couldn't care less whether or not alcohol was available for my consumption, besides purchasing a mini bottle of Irish Cream Whiskey once a year to use like vanilla extract in frosting and chocolates, I have little use for the substance. I must admit, I do like my deserts to have a little sting sometimes, but this is hardly enough for even a mild buzz, but I digress.

So, lately I have been thinking that maybe this wise old uncle had something to his statement. A friend of mine recently confessed to me that she used to "have to" tip back a margarita before coming to my home for supper. The thought of not having an alcoholic beverage available was too much for her at the time. This made me inwardly recoil and feel sort of disgusted. I mean, come on, are you freakin' kidding me, you can't go 3 hours without a drink. I think my expression as usual gave me away and she explained. "oh, it wasn't you, I just used to feel like I needed a drink to feel free, to unwind and be fun."

I guess this is my biggest problem with alcohol consumption. The fact that some people feel like they "have to" have it to have a good time. It's pathetic, and come on, have you ever smelled wine? Nasty. I think very few people thought "this tastes awesome" the first time they tasted rotten vine or frothy beer. Any taste that needs to be acquired should just as well be left alone for the most part, including dandelion greens.

I could go on and on, but I will not today. I acknowledge my biased, and feel thankful for it.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

There is such a hypocrisy often with laws and views of alcohol and drugs. I mean its pretty strange that people do not think of alcohol or cigarettes as drugs but marijuana they do. There are also a number of herbs and natural things that are also drugs where some are illegal and others are not.

I kind of like the Dutch approach where they define it as 'soft drugs' or 'hard drugs'. This distinction looks at all drugs including alcohol, cigarettes, mushrooms, herbs and other things. They basically make a priority as to how to handle it in law enforcement, drug education and prevention. This way they tackle self-esteem, home environments and other influences without wasting money just throwing people in jail where they only learn about hard drug use, crime and more despair.

Comparatively they have a very low drug use rate. Just today I was walking past a so-called 'coffee shop' which here, is a place to smoke weed. It was full of Americans and Brits and no Dutch at all.

Obviously forbidding alcohol didn't work. They've already tried that. I truly think education and a strong self worth is the ticket. If everyone felt good about themselves the world would be such a better place. :D

fitzhamilton said...

Well, this is a fundamental thing. One of the many dissonances I have (as a Catholic) with the LDS..

I've been praying the mystery of the Wedding at Cana a lot lately, and a couple weeks ago, I sat down and did the math on the 6 stone jars - Luke tells us they each held between 20 and 30 gallons. That's between 120 and 180 gallons, total. In modern terms, that's between 600 and some 900 750 ml bottles..

This after, as the Evangelist tells us, "they had already drunk freely," of what the steward characterized as "poorer wine" - And the reason you serve the poor wine after the good, my little Mormon friend, is because after you are already inebriated, you can't taste the difference..

The wedding party must have been large.. But even if there were 4 - 500 people, and even if the wine was not as potent as modern wine (say, more like the strength of beer) - both of which postulates (the second being dubious, grapes ferment the same way always and everywhere, which means to generally 9- 14% alcohol) tee- totaling puritans often use with me, to try to defend themselves from their own weak consciences - see 1 Cor 8 ) .. The fact still remains that those people drank, and drank a lot.

And it was Christ who provided the wine.

Just as at the Last Supper (prefigured at Cana) he established the Eucharist, again using wine.

Which is to say that the "unrestored" Church hews to the ancient practice established by the Master Himself, and that we thus must drink wine.

And that if there were a return to Prohibition, we Catholics (and Orthodox, and Orthodox Jews) would all need to resort to civil disobedience to practice our Faith.

As for wine being disgusting .. ah, poor Ave. Poor Ave. You really have *no* idea of what you speak. I always pity the LDS missionaries here, when they eat with me. Because they will never experience the full beauty of a meal here. Eating without wine in Europe (but especially Italy, France and Spain) is an obscene act, bordering on self- mutilation.

You had eyes, but you never did see. A tongue, yet you never tasted..

"Taste and See, the LORD is good.."

That's antipasti, primo, secundo, contorno, e dolci con vino *e* caffè, as well the Eucharist, so you know..

Enjoying reading this by the by..

Funny stuff.